top of page

The More Doors You Own, the Better the Investment. Right?

Oct 29
7 min read

FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF UNPOPULAR FINANCIAL TRUTHS

Because somebody has to read the fine print.


The More Doors You Own, the Better the Investment. Right?


Why a twelve-unit apartment building isn't automatically a better investment than a single rental property — regardless of what the guy selling the real estate course says.


Somewhere right now, someone is telling a room full of investors to think bigger


You know the presentation. A photograph of a beautiful apartment building. A slide showing twelve streams of rental income. Some impressive-looking numbers. And a presenter explaining why serious real estate investors don't waste their time buying single-family homes.


"Think about it. Would you rather collect rent from one tenant or twelve?"


Well, twelve does sound rather appealing. Twelve tenants, twelve rental payments, twelve opportunities to build wealth — and twelve opportunities for someone to call you on a Sunday because the plumbing has developed a personality of its own. That part doesn't tend to make it onto the slide.


And somewhere in the audience, an investor who was perfectly happy owning one rental property an hour ago is now wondering whether they've been doing real estate investing wrong.


They haven't actually compared the investments. They haven't looked at the financing, the expenses or the cash flow.


But twelve doors certainly sound more impressive than one.


Unfortunately, the number of front doors isn't a measure of investment quality. And the tax consequences don't become more attractive simply because the building has a bigger parking lot.


What investors expect vs. what actually happens

What investors expect 

What actually happens 

"Twelve units mean twelve times the income." 

More gross rent also brings more operating expenses, maintenance responsibilities and capital requirements. 

"If one tenant leaves, I still have eleven paying." 

Vacancy risk is spread across units, but a building may still face concentrated market, financing and major-repair risks. 

"Larger properties are more profitable." 

Profitability depends on purchase price, net operating income, financing costs and required capital expenditures — not unit count. 

"The tax deductions will be much better." 

Generally, the same underlying Canadian rental-income tax principles apply. More expenses aren't automatically a tax advantage. 

"The property pays for itself." 

That depends on whether its income covers operating costs, debt service, capital reserves and other cash requirements. 


Notice that none of this says multifamily investing is a bad idea. It says the investment has to be judged on something more meaningful than how many front doors appear in the listing.


Gross rent is what the tenants pay. Cash flow is what's left.


Here's where real estate presentations can become rather creative.


An investor considers a twelve-unit building generating $18,000 per month — $216,000 a year. Impressive. A single-family rental down the road brings in $2,800 a month, or $33,600. Clearly the building wins.


Except we haven't compared the investments. We've compared their gross rental income, which is a little like comparing two businesses by their sales without asking whether either makes money.


Property taxes, insurance, utilities, management, maintenance and vacancies all reduce what's available to service debt. Then come the mortgage payments. Then the capital expenditures — because roofs don't last forever, boilers break at inconvenient moments, and twelve kitchens contain considerably more things that can stop working than one.


A property producing $216,000 in gross rent might be an excellent investment. It might also be a very expensive way of discovering that you've purchased a building with inadequate operating income.


The rent tells you what comes in. The analysis tells you what might stay.


So, let's actually run them

Two hypothetical properties, same financing assumptions for both: 25% down, annual debt service equal to about 6% of the original mortgage principal, and a 5% vacancy allowance each. Illustrative figures, not market quotes or financing offers.


Annual analysis 

Single-family rental 

Twelve-unit building 

Purchase price 

$420,000 

$2,400,000 

Initial equity (25%) 

$105,000 

$600,000 

Gross scheduled rent 

$33,600 

$216,000 

Vacancy allowance (5%) 

($1,680) 

($10,800) 

Operating expenses 

($8,600) 

($80,000) 

Net operating income 

$23,320 

$125,200 

Annual debt service 

($18,900) 

($108,000) 

Cash flow before reserves 

$4,420 

$17,200 

Illustrative capital reserve 

($3,000) 

($15,000) 

Cash flow after reserve, before income tax 

$1,420 

$2,200 

Cash-on-cash return on equity 

1.35% 

0.37% 


Read the last row again.


The building produces more than six times the rent and more than five times the net operating income. It also produces roughly a quarter of the return on the money actually invested.


Here's what's interesting. On a price-to-gross-rent basis, the building initially looks like the better bargain — about eleven times annual rent against twelve and a half for the house. The financing assumptions are identical. So is the vacancy allowance. But gross rent doesn't pay the mortgage. What matters is how much survives after the operating bills have been paid.


In this example, the house retains about 69 cents of every rental dollar as net operating income. The building retains only 58 cents. The difference is in the operating costs, not the number of doors.


That's the whole argument in one table. Twelve doors generated six times the revenue and less than half the return.


One qualification, because the distinction matters given the title of this article: that last row compares annual cash returns, not total investment returns. Mortgage principal repayment, changes in property value and the tax consequences on eventual sale all shape the longer-term picture, and none of them appear in that table. A better cash-on-cash return is not the same thing as a better investment.


Change the assumptions and the conclusion changes with them — a lower purchase price, better rents or leaner operations could easily reverse it. That's the point. The investment isn't good or bad because it's one unit or twelve. It's good or bad because of the economics of the particular deal.


And about that reserve. Suppose the building needs a $180,000 roof. That's $15,000 per unit, which sounds rather more manageable than $180,000 — until you remember that the roofing contractor expects to be paid in dollars rather than in reassuring per-unit averages. At $15,000 a year, the reserve in that table covers the roof in twelve years, assuming nothing else breaks in the meantime.


Because an investment that only works if nothing expensive breaks isn't resilient. It's optimistic. There is a difference.


The vacancy argument is real. But it isn't the whole story.

One of the strongest arguments for multifamily investing is tenant diversification, and it deserves to be taken seriously.


Lose the tenant in a single-family property and you've lost 100% of the rent until it's re-let. With twelve occupied units, one vacancy is roughly 8.3% of potential income. That's a meaningful difference and a genuine advantage.


But diversification within one building isn't diversification across a portfolio. Twelve units share more than an address — the same roof, heating system, insurance policy, municipal tax environment and local rental market. When a major system fails, the expense doesn't politely limit itself to one-twelfth of the building. When local employment conditions turn, multiple units turn with them.


Neither arrangement eliminates risk. They distribute it differently.


The deduction is not the return

Real estate investors love talking about deductions. Mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, repairs, management fees — and, inevitably, depreciation, or capital cost allowance as we call it here.


Spending a dollar to save a portion of that dollar in tax is not a wealth-building strategy.


Spend $10,000 on an otherwise deductible expense at a 40% effective marginal rate and you may reduce tax by roughly $4,000. You have still spent $10,000. A larger building may produce larger deductions for the straightforward reason that it incurs larger expenses, which is not the same as producing a better result.


CCA deserves one specific caution: it can make taxable income look quite different from cash flow, land isn't depreciable, and CCA generally cannot be used to create or increase an overall rental loss. More importantly, claiming it during ownership can have consequences on sale, where previously claimed CCA may be recaptured into income. Tax saved along the way shouldn't be considered in isolation from tax payable at the end. 


There is one real exception on unit count, and it cuts the other way from the seminar pitch. Qualifying new purpose-built rental housing can attract an accelerated 10% CCA rate rather than the standard 4%, subject to the legislated unit, rental and construction requirements. So the number of units can matter for tax — but what the measure rewards is building new rental housing, not buying an existing forty-year-old walk-up.


In other words, buying more doors doesn't automatically unlock a better tax deduction. CRA is rather more interested in whether the building qualifies than how impressive your property portfolio looks on Instagram.


Approval isn't an opinion, and the exit isn't an afterthought

Two things the presentation tends to skip.


A lender agreeing to finance a property doesn't establish that the investment is attractive. It establishes that the transaction meets the lender's requirements. Those are two different tests, and only one of them is about you.


And the exit matters as much as the purchase. Single-family properties may appeal to investors and owner-occupiers both. Larger buildings are generally bought by investors pricing them off income and required returns — so a shift in market capitalization rates can move the building's value even where its rent doesn't move at all. Selling also triggers tax consequences, which may include capital gains and CCA recapture depending on the facts.


Neither belongs at the end of the analysis. Both belong before the offer.


So, which one is better?

It depends — and not the evasive kind of "it depends." It depends on the purchase price, the financing, the condition of the property, the equity required and what the investor is actually trying to achieve.


The questions worth asking are unglamorous:


  • What is the property's sustainable net operating income?

  • How much equity is required, including acquisition costs and initial reserves?

  • What happens if vacancies rise or financing costs increase?

  • What capital expenditures are likely over the ownership period, and does the reserve realistically cover them?

  • Does the investment still work if the optimistic assumptions don't materialize?


None of those will make an exciting slide. They're considerably more likely to tell you whether the deal works.


The unglamorous conclusion

There is something deeply appealing about the idea that building a real estate portfolio is just a matter of accumulating doors. One becomes four. Four becomes twelve. Twelve becomes fifty. And somewhere along the way, according to the internet, financial freedom arrives in a luxury vehicle.


Some investors will build substantial wealth through single-family properties. Others will do so through multifamily buildings. And some will discover, rather expensively, that a larger portfolio can simply mean a larger collection of financial problems.


The number of units is a measurement of scale. It isn't a measurement of investment quality.


The goal isn't to own more doors. It's to own investments that actually work.


Which, admittedly, makes for a considerably less exciting presentation than a photograph of an apartment building accompanied by the words "PASSIVE INCOME."



The Department of Unpopular Financial Truths


This article provides general information about Canadian real estate investing and taxation. It is not individualized tax, legal, financing or investment advice. The comparison above is illustrative and excludes acquisition costs, mortgage principal repayment, changes in property value and income taxes. Property returns and tax outcomes depend on the particular investment, ownership structure and circumstances. Obtain appropriate professional advice before making investment decisions.

Comments


bottom of page